President Obama had another excellent Q&A today, this time with Democratic Senators. During the course of the event, he got a “question” from Wal-Mart’s own Senator Lincoln. Let’s break her “question” down and the President’s response…
Let’s look at Lincoln’s first:
Me, neither, Mr. President. I stay away from the TVs and everything else.
Total bullshit. (This was in response to something the President had said earlier about turning off the television…and blogs…)
But thank you so much for being here with us today. And I want to thank you also — I had an opportunity with several of my colleagues from the House and Senate to have a bipartisan meeting yesterday with the First Lady on childhood obesity. It was a great meeting and we look forward to working with her and you and your administration to really tackle that problem on behalf of our children and the future of our country.
Okay, that’s nice and all, but getting to the point was never Blanche’s strong point.
Mr. President, I come from a seventh-generation Arkansas family. My dad was a good Democrat, and he was a great Arkansan, and he was very typical of Arkansans in that he was very independent-minded, as am I, and as most of my constituents. And he used to tell me early on when I ran for Congress, he said it’s really results that count.
Really Blanche? You who have stood in the way of Democrats, scratch that, of Congress getting any real results on much of anything over the course of more than a year have the audacity to say that?
And as I look at what’s going on in my state and among my constituents — I visited with a constituent yesterday, good Democrat, small business owner, who was extremely frustrated — extremely frustrated because there was a lack of certainty and predictability from his government for him to be able to run his businesses. He’s — he and his father have worked hard, they’ve built three or four different small businesses, and he fears that there’s no one in your administration that understands what it means to go to work on Monday and have to make a payroll on Friday. He wants results. He wants predictability.
Translation: Mr. President, I think your pinko commie policies are jeopardizing my reelection bid and I’d really prefer it if you just went back and did the things that President Bush and I supported in the past. After all, you’re really not looking out for those mom and pop businesses like Wal-Mart, and Tyson Foods, and Blue Cross-Blue Sheild.
And I think that you’re exactly right. People out there watching us, they see us nothing more than Democrats and Republicans up here fighting, fighting only to win a few political points, not to get the problem solved. And so I just — I want to echo I guess some of what my colleague, Michael Bennet from Colorado, mentioned, but also to ask you, in terms of where we are going, what can we tell the people in terms of predictability and certainty in getting this economy back on track? How are we going to do that?
Why did she even bother asking that? She’s just going to come out against anything and everything he says. Is she just trying to get an idea how to best pull off tomorrow morning’s backstab?
And are we willing as Democrats not only to reach out to Republicans but to push back in our own party for people who want extremes, and look for the common ground that’s going to get us the success that we need not only for our constituents but for our country in this global community, in this global economy? Are we willing as Democrats to also push back on our own party and look for that common ground that we need to work with Republicans and to get the answers? And it’s really the results that are going to count to our constituents. And we appreciate the hard work that you put into it.
Translation: Those awful librul’s are being mean to me! They’re even trying to get someone to primary me! They must be Marxists for wanting to do that! Please Mr. President, it would help me politically if you’d say just the tiniest thing for me to throw in their faces, even though I’m still going to do everything I can to derail your radical, leftist agenda. (Remember, do what George Bush and I supported!) And seriously, who do these radicals think they are! All these workers, and people concerned about the air they breathe, and those damn sick people wanting health care! Don’t they see that by denying workers’ rights, supporting polluters, and derailing meaningful health care reform that I’m pursuing a moderate, common sense agenda!
Now, for President Obama’s response…
Well, the — look, there’s no doubt that this past year has been an uncertain time for the American people, for businesses and for people employed by businesses. Some of that certainty just had to do with the objective reality of this economy entering into a freefall. So let’s just be — let’s remind ourselves that if you’ve got an economy suddenly contracting by 6 percent, or a loss of trillions of dollars of wealth basically in the blink of an eye, or home values descending by 20 percent, that that’s going to create a whole lot of uncertainty out there in the business environment and among families.
And part of what we’ve done over the course of this year is to put a floor under people’s feet. That’s what the Recovery Act did. That’s what the interventions and the financial markets did. It broke the back of the recession, stabilized the markets. Nobody is talking about a market meltdown at this point. And people haven’t recovered all that they had lost in their 401(k)s, but they’re feeling a little better when they open that envelope now than they did six months ago. State budgets were in freefall; that was stabilized. States are still going through incredible pain, but they did not have to lay off teachers and firefighters and cops at the levels that they would have to otherwise lay them off. That provided some stability and some certainty.
So the steps you’ve taken as a Congress, the steps we’ve taken as an administration, have helped to stabilize things.
Translation: Senator, you really don’t know what you’re talking about.
Now, moving forward, Blanche, what you’re going to hear from some folks is that the way to achieve even greater economic growth — and keep in mind the economy is now growing at a 6 percent clip, so the question is when do businesses actually start hiring, because they’re now making a profit — what you’re going to start hearing is the only way to provide stability is to go back and do what we’d been doing before the crisis.
So I noticed yesterday when we were — there was some hearing about our proposal to provide additional financing to small businesses and tax credits to small businesses. Some of our friends on the other side of the aisle said, “This won’t help at all. What you have to do is to make sure that we continue the tax breaks for wealthiest Americans. That’s really what’s going to make a difference.”
Well, if the agenda — if the price of certainty is essentially for us to adopt the exact same proposals that were in place for eight years leading up to the biggest economic crisis since the Great Depression — we don’t tinker with health care, let the insurance companies do what they want, we don’t put in place any insurance reforms, we don’t mess with the banks, let them keep on doing what they’re doing now because we don’t want to stir up Wall Street — the result is going to be the same.
Translation: Tell your corporate financers to go jump off a bridge. I am not going to use my Presidency to advance an agenda that was proven to be bad for America for eight long and miserable years so they’ll keep lining your campaign coffers and give you that cushy job when you lose your reelection bid. Bottom line, I’m not going to let you and the Republicans take us over a cliff…again.
I don’t know why we would expect a different outcome pursuing the exact same policies that got us into this fix in the first place. Michael Bennet articulated it very well. Part of the reason people are feeling anxious right now, it’s not just because of this current crisis — they’ve been going through this for 10 years. They’ve been working and not seeing a raise. Their costs have been going up, their spouses going to the workforce — they work as hard as they can. They’re barely keeping their heads above water. They’re trying to figure out how to retire. They’re seeing more and more of their costs on health care dumped in their lap. College tuition skyrockets.
They are more and more vulnerable, and they have been for the last decade, treading water. And if our response ends up being, because we don’t want to — we don’t want to stir things up here, we’re just going to do the same thing that was being done before, then I don’t know what differentiates us from the other guys. And I don’t know why people would say, boy, we really want to make sure that those Democrats are in Washington fighting for us.
Translation: Blanche, the reason you’re going to lose is because your constituents don’t think you care about them. They think (or rather know) that you’re looking out for big business first and foremost, and that there’s no reason to vote for you. And if Democrats follow your path it will insure we lose big in November, just like you’re set to do.
So the point I’m making — and Blanche is exactly right — we’ve got to be non-ideological about our approach to these things. We’ve got to make sure that our party understands that, like it or not, we have to have a financial system that is healthy and functioning, so we can’t be demonizing every bank out there. We’ve got to be the party of business, small business and large business, because they produce jobs. We’ve got to be in favor of competition and exports and trade. We don’t want to be looking backwards. We can’t just go back to the New Deal and try to grab all the same policies of the 1930s and think somehow they’d work in the 21st century.
I started to groan when he said this, and mark my words, if Lincoln does face a primary we’re going to hear this line again and again. Still, the President shifted on it nicely, refusing to play into her hands. Read on-
So Blanche is exactly right that sometimes we get ideologically bogged down. I just want to find out what works, and I know you do, too, and I know the people in Arkansas do, too. But when you’re talking to the folks in Arkansas you also have to remind them what works is not just going back and doing the same things that we were doing before. And, yes, there’s going to be some transition time. If we have a serious financial regulatory reform package, will the banks squawk? Yes. Will they say this is the reason we’re not lending? Yes. The problem is we know right now they’re not lending, and paying out big bonuses. And we know that the existing regulatory system doesn’t work.
So we shouldn’t be spooked by this notion that, well, is now the time to take seriously in an intelligent way, not in a knee-jerk way, the challenge of financial regulatory reform so that you don’t have banks that are too big to fail and you’re not putting taxpayers at risk and you’re not putting the economy at risk — now is the time to do it.
The same is true with health care. The same is true with health care. There are, I promise you, at least as many small businesses out there, if you talk to them, who will say, I just got my bill from my health insurance and it went up 40 percent. And we’ve got to do something for them. All right?
The President effectively attacked Lincoln’s implication that his agenda was in any way ideological. He defended his agenda, and the Democratic agenda I might add, as being right for America, and he essentially told Lincoln to act like a Democrat and open her eyes to see that he was trying to do what’s right for the whole country, including Arkansas. (Not that Senator Lincoln really cares about Arkansas of course.) And notice, he specifically rubbed her nose in health care, the issue she’s been a particular thorn in all our sides on.
Blanche bit off more than she could chew with this one. I don’t know why she went in their with this fake “question”-this long winded, almost babbling, assertion that the President’s agenda is too far to the left and that he needs to move right while giving her ammunition to fire back at her critics. I guess ultimately all she really proved is what we already know, that she has a real political tin ear. And you know, as I watched Obama getting ready to respond to her I had to think that he was putting together the right words to tell her what he’s probably wanted to say to her for half a year now in the nicest way possible. And then he just let her have it, in his typical nice, even handed, charming way.
Oh, and by the way, your’s truly is quite happy to be counted as an extremist element by Blanche Lincoln, and I will continue to work and fight for such radical causes as universal health care, workers’ rights, civil and human rights, protecting the environment, having a sensible foreign policy, and making sure that our economy works for everyone. You know, all those Marxist notions…